When we make tool comparison, sometimes it becomes confusing because of the similar features and workability of the tools. No matter if you are an amateur or professional, it is a must to keep a power saw in your collection.
But then the dilemma arises if to go for a jigsaw or a circular saw, both the saws have relevant attributes and working capacity that works great on wooden projects. There remains a fine line which makes them different from one another.
That is why you are supposed to know every functional detail of each of the tools. Proper knowledge will guide you for taking the best decision according to the necessity of your work.
Brief Discussion on Jigsaw
Jigsaws are available in a wide range of varieties based on different needs of users. The information that a buyer should have with him beforehand are as follows;
What is Jigsaw?
A jigsaw is one of the most versatile power tools allowing the user to make different types of cuts such as long, straight, curved, diagonal, etc. It is featured with a long knife-like blade, and it moves in an up-down motion to cut through the materials.
Apart from a variety of cuts, it can work on a wide range of materials such as wood, plywood, plastic and even ceramic tile. You just need to choose the right kind of blade to get the desired outcome.
The Functionality of a Jigsaw
- Cutting Variety: A jigsaw is capable of making different types of cuts from long straight to beveled. Even inclined and diagonal cuts can also be done by this tool.
- Versatile Material: A jigsaw can be called as a ‘one-man army’ if we wanted to personify it. If you have a jigsaw in your store, you are ready to pull off any kind of carpenter work. It can work with various kinds of wood but choosing the right type of blade is the primary concern here.
- Plunge Cuts: Another surprising feature of a jigsaw is that it can make plunge cuts, which means you can make your cut from the center of your material, not confined at edges only.
- Handy and Portable: Another best thing is this tool will not capture any significant space of your storage. You can just keep it at any corner of your house.
Limitations of a Jigsaw
- Less Accuracy: You should consider that, after all, it is a handheld tool. Which means there is enough scope of making mistakes from your end. Also, you cannot expect the cut to be 100% accurate.
- Not Stable: Jigsaw bounces a lot. Hence if you are experienced enough, might lose control at a certain point. Also, it makes it difficult to cut a long and straight line for a beginner.
- Can make curved cuts
- The blade is smaller making it safe to use
- Produces less debris while working
- Ensures quicker cut on various materials
- Not suitable for heavy-duty jobs
- The blades can break very easily
- Unable to make extended straight cuts
- The tools are not stable; bounces while working
Brief Discussion on Circular Saw
Here, the accuracy of the cutting depends on the type of blade inserted. Most of the circular saws are featured with 24 tooth blade. Still, you can upgrade it to 50 tooth blade for a neat cutting. It is mainly functioned for a straight cut but also capable of curved cutting.
What is a Circular Saw?
A circular saw is another useful power tool. It comes with a round circular blade with a sharpened teethed edge which moves in a rotary motion cutting through the objects. Like the jigsaw, a circular saw can also cut through various materials like wood, plywood, plastic, metal sheet, etc.
The Functionality of a Circular Saw
- Smooth Straight Cuts: Most of the wooden projects require a straight cut. A circular saw can ensure you an accurate and extended straight cut. It has e rotary disc-shaped blade which makes it very easy and smooth to cut through the material and make straight cuts.
- Versatile Material: A circular saw is capable of cutting through various materials. Its functionality is not confined within woods only. This tool can also work on plywood, plastic, metal sheets and pipe. You might need to change the blade according to the type of material.
- Cutting Variety: The functionality of circular saw is not confined within straight cuts only. It is also able to make smooth angled cut and rough beveled rips.
Limitation of a Circular Saw
- Unsmooth Finishing: Though circular saws can make faster straight cuts, it cannot ensure smooth edges.
- Unable to make the curved cut: If your task requires smoothly curved cuts, then circular saw should not be your option. This tool is specialized to make straight cuts, but not smooth curve cuts.
- Able to cut through thick wooden piles smoothly
- Can make long straight cuts within seconds
- The blades are stronger and durable
- Suitable for heavy-duty jobs
- Cannot make curve cuts
- Creates noise and debris at the workstation
- It is comparatively heavier
- Risky to use; the blade can cause fatal accidents
Jigsaw vs Circular Saw: Comparison at a Glance
|Cutting Variety||Able to make straight, curved, diagonal cuts||Mostly reliable for straight cuts only|
|Smoothness||Ensures smoothness of the edge||Unable to make a smooth edge|
|Straight cut||Cannot make extended straight cuts||Makes longer straight cuts precisely|
|Bouncing||Jigsaw bounces||Circular saw do not bounce|
If your project requires delicate tasks, then jigsaw can be the best option for you. Apart from a small straight line, it makes the curved cuts, plunges very smoothly with a neat finishing edge.
But if you are working on a heavy-duty project like building a home or garage, then circular saw should be the best option. It is capable of doing heavy-duty jobs and cuts volumes of wooden piles.
The jigsaw and the circular saw both are very handy and easy to operate. If you are a beginner, you better pick one tool based on the type of work you want to pursue. But in the long run, you will not regret if you buy both the tools as each of them are very functional and useful as per their added features.